Much of this blog post is about transport, but it’s mostly simply observational, not looking in-depth… I wonder if I should put these in a different category or something?
What happens when I combine my interests of retro video games and public transport? This: I spent a few hours on a train out to Bendigo and back to hunt down an Atari 2600 cartridge at Cash Converters.
I recently bought an Atari 2600+, which is a replica gaming console with mod cons such as HDMI out. It plays original cartridges (for the 2600 and 7800), which you can often find second-hand. There’s plenty on eBay, but Cash Converters stores also sometimes have them.
So on a day off, I went to Southern Cross and hopped on a train to Bendigo. The line runs mostly hourly outside peak.
It was a 3 car train, and busy, but not packed – unlike my last trip to Ballarat. But this was a weekday – the Bendigo line is known for bad crowding on weekends when 3 cars simply don’t cope with demand.
It’s rather nice to sit back and relax and watch the countryside fly by.
The off-peak services are timed to take 111 minutes for the 162 Km journey to Bendigo, an average speed (including stops) of 88 Km/hour. (Insert a metric Back To The Future joke here.)
On arrival in Bendigo, I walked down Mitchell Street towards Pall Mall. There seemed to be a lot of buses heading up to the station. I’m guessing they run a pulse-type service meeting the hourly trains. This is good – and helps explain why the station bus interchange was so busy with passengers.
Bike racks are common on Bendigo buses, though I didn’t see any actually in use. They arguably make more sense in regional towns than in metropolitan Melbourne. I know some people really like them, and I’m keeping an open mind, but I’m conscious of the fact that they don’t scale up well, and most of the world’s biggest, busiest city bus networks don’t usually have them.
Fairly quickly I found the Cash Converters and bought the cartridge – a home version of the arcade game Jungle Hunt, a game with themes which I suspect wouldn’t pass muster these days… but one I fondly remember from back in the day thanks to the fun gameplay. $10 – Bargain!
The bloke in the shop remarked that they hadn’t had a chance to test it, and extended the somewhat ungenerous short 24 hour warranty up to 30 days. (Spoiler: it worked perfectly.)
Near the shop I spotted what looked part of an old tram used as a part of a stop for the heritage tram. After pondering this, I looked for somewhere to have lunch.
Conscious of time until the hourly train, I ate a fairly mediocre sandwich in the Hargreaves Mall, as nearby a two person band played to a one person audience. It was pretty hot – not great outdoor shopping weather, even with free entertainment.
Then I walked a circuitous way back to the station – inevitably passing any number of nicer looking cafes with nicer looking food – and caught the train back.
The train back to Melbourne was one of the higher capacity short haul sets (designation “VR”), designed for commuter traffic, with more (less roomy) seats, only one toilet per 3 cars, and fewer bicycle storage spaces. They were introduced in 2018, with Bicycle Network in particular critical of the design.
If these trains were used in the intended way, you wouldn’t see them on the 2 hour Bendigo to Melbourne service; they’d be confined to short commuter runs such as Melton and Wyndham Vale.
But in reality they seem to show up randomly on any service on the network. One almost suspects V/Line treats all their VLocity trains as a one-size-fits-all, apart from Standard Gauge sets dedicated to the Albury line… and that’s only because they physically can’t fit on the other tracks.
On our trip, the lack of bike spaces did indeed cause issues, with the conductor having to guide cyclists to the correct door to load their bike, resulting in short delays at some stations.
But there was worse to come – a disruption on the line ahead at Albion (on the shared Metro and V/Line track) meant we came to a halt for about 45 minutes just outside Sunbury.
Thankfully the train wasn’t full, so the one toilet coped with the longer than usual travel time. The conductor gave us plenty of updates.
A slower-than-usual run the rest of the way meant we arrived in Melbourne about an hour late.
For some reason the live updates on V/Line’s app flagged a delay with the earlier service, but not ours.
Thankfully I wasn’t trying to make a tight connection – my train the rest of the way home runs every 10 minutes.
(An hour or two later there were more severe disruptions on numerous V/Line lines, hitting evening peak and affecting a lot more people.)
So, any conclusions from this day out?
- V/Line on weekdays is less crowded than weekends
- …but reliability certainly isn’t perfect (and online information can be patchy)
- It didn’t cause big problems this time, but they really should try and keep the short distance VR sets on short distance services
- Connections are easy and stress-free when you’re connecting to a frequent service… not so much when you’re connecting to an infrequent one
- Timetable co-ordination between trains and buses is a good thing!
- I still enjoy playing Jungle Hunt.
7 replies on “Bendigo Bargain Hunt”
Regards to lunch, you should have used the solution to the secretary problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secretary_problem So optimally estimate there are 10 lunch places call this n, view the first n/e places (e.g. 10/2.7818=4 say), then eat the next one that is better than what you saw or failing that the last one. Mind you I look at them all, get really hungry and eat something really bad where the hunger and frustration strikes.
I was unfortunate enough to catch a VR set last week to Kyneton. I did had no chance of fitting in the seats (I’m 198cm tall) and got off with a very sore back :-( The lack of facing seats is also an annoyance (we had a group of 3) – the solo guy who got on in front of us took the only set in our half of the carriage for himself and his bag :-| )
Do Bendigo buses not use the standard PTV livery? I remember the very old but similarly coloured Bendigo Bus livery from the 80s.
The seats on that type of V/Locity are also less comfortable and the tray table doesn’t really take a laptop properly – although that’s better than the V/Locities that don’t have a tray table at all.
Is there a reason that Bendigo trains don’t stop at Sunshine?
Unrelated, but on the broad topic of trains that don’t stop at Sunshine. The summary PIDs at Geelong (those without the list of stops) describe the up Warrnambool trains as Limited Express just like all other up Geelong trains. While station staff are at pains to announce that the trains only stop at Footscray and Southern Cross, one wonders whether any passengers have been taken hostage since the locos were replaced with V/Locities! I suspect so – I was on one recently that had to make an unscheduled stop at Wyndham Vale to let an unruly passenger off, and he wasn’t the only person to get off!
@Alex, the carriage I was in had some facing seats – not sure if there are a few variations?
@Steve, none of the Bendigo local buses I saw used the PTV livery, though I’ve previously noticed a bus on the Bendigo to Heathcote route that does use it. https://www.flickr.com/photos/danielbowen/51921180156/
Bendigo trains don’t stop at Sunshine basically due to platform capacity, and I guess a wish for consistent patterns. I believe the intention is that they will commence stopping at Sunshine when the proposed 5th platform is built.
V/Line run four types of Vlocity trains (Standard VL (00-75, 99+), VL with crap seats (80-92), VR (76-79), and Standard Gauge) but everything other than the standard gauge stock is treated as one group. If they only ran the VR and crap seated VL trains to Wyndham Vale, they would have a fleet that hardly gains mileage, isn’t wearing at the same rate as the others and would need their own maintenance cycle.
So from and operational perspective they are right to treat them all the same. The failure is not with V/Line, but with the government, for creating this situation in the first place. Units 75-92 need to be converted to match the rest of the fleet. But ultimately, we shouldn’t even be building the antiquated Vlocity trains anymore. It’s been almost 20 years. Time for a new modern train type to be developed.
You were unlucky, I believe. I caught trains to and from Bendigo every two weeks for a couple of years and never uncounted disruptions.
@Flanders, thanks – that makes sense.
Yes, it’s amazing that they’re still making VLocities some 22 years after the first were built.