Categories
The week in transport transport

Weekly cap: good idea, but…

Just for a moment we were ahead of the game on public transport ticketing.

Victoria was behind most of the rest of Australia in getting Tap And Go/Contactless bank card payments on public transport – though we were about in the middle of the pack worldwide.

We jumped ahead of most other Australian jurisdictions by getting concessions working with Tap and Go earlier this month.

In Australia, only Sydney and Canberra were ahead of us on this, and it’s relatively rare to have this capability internationally.

Myki poster promoting Tap And Go

Just when our ticketing system had caught up with systems in other cities, then Labor made an election promise of a $30 weekly cap… but only for Myki card users.

A weekly cap is a very good idea, but politically this is not a good look.

Until now there’s been fare parity for Tap And Go vs Myki users for 2-hour and daily fares. Charging the same is what you want to encourage more usage of public transport. New and occasional public transport users who don’t want to mess with Myki will likely prefer Tap And Go, but they also don’t want to pay more than necessary.

(Perth charges more for all Tap And Go fares; I’m not sure I understand why.)

Assuming Labour is re-elected in November, the $30 weekly cap would eventually reach Tap and Go users too. As I understand it’s linked to the planned change to Account-Based Ticketing, which moves more functionality onto the back end systems, and provides better capability to adjust fares for things like off-peak discounts and additional caps.

It’s interesting that Myki cards are capable of a weekly cap but Tap and Go currently isn’t, but both offer a daily cap. Possibly this is due to Myki having originally included a weekly cap that was never turned on.

Outbound train at Malvern, waiting for departure time

The idea of an automatic weekly cap is a very good one. It means people using the system 5+ days a week are not disadvantaged because they did not preload a Weekly Pass – this is a process that is confusing for passengers, and unnecessarily time-consuming.

The weekly cap is also good for people on limited incomes who don’t necessarily want to pay upfront for a pass.

$30 is a pretty big discount compared to the normal weekly fare – $57 for 5 days of travel or a Weekly Pass. But that’s partly because our Weekly Pass is expensive.

The discount brings it down to the cost of 2.6 weekday daily fares, the same as in Paris and Sydney (daily pass/cap vs weekly), though the prices are higher in both those cities. Some other cities have weekly caps which are a bit higher in proportion to daily fares.

The weekly cap plan does nothing for the high cost of short distance fares. But it would help encourage regular users, and is a good idea.

What happens will depend on the election result. But hopefully whoever gets into government will implement a weekly cap for all users as soon as possible.

By Daniel Bowen

Transport blogger / campaigner and spokesperson for the Public Transport Users Association / professional geek.
Bunurong land, Melbourne, Australia.
Opinions on this blog are all mine.

2 replies on “Weekly cap: good idea, but…”

Perthโ€™s fare discounts preference the methods of payment that have the lowest administrative cost with the greatest discount. So direct-debit auto-loaded Easyrider cards get the greatest discount; manually loaded Easyrider cards get a lower discount; and pay-per-trip fares get no discount.

@Michael, some auto correct going on there?

Yes, that all makes sense. But Tap And Go further reduces the administrative cost… once the system is running, the PT authority does not have to issue those cards, nor do those passengers use the vending machines.

So what surprises me is that Perth Tap And Go users get charged the higher cash fare, not the Smartrider fare.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *